Annual performance review
A structured annual performance review with achievements, competency ratings, goals, and growth areas. Built for managers who want a substantive conversation, not a checkbox.
Annual Performance Review
· Period:
Employee: · Role: · Manager:
1. Key achievements
2. Impact
3. Competencies
Execution:
Collaboration:
Craft / technical:
Ownership:
4. Growth areas
Page 1 of 3
5. Goals for the next period
6. Overall summary
7. Employee self-assessment
Page 2 of 3
Made with WalnutsHR Paper · Reviewed for Ontario · April 2026
Page 3 of 3
No compliance hints for this jurisdiction yet — your document looks good for the basics. Have a lawyer review before sending anything consequential.
About this template
An annual performance review is the formal record of how an employee performed against expectations over a year. It feeds compensation decisions, growth plans, and — when things go wrong — the documentary trail a tribunal will read. Done thoughtfully, it's also one of the highest-leverage management conversations of the year.
When to use it
- You're running an annual or semi-annual review cycle and need a consistent template across the team.
- You're documenting an employee's performance for a compensation, promotion, or development decision.
- You want to anchor the next year's goals in a written record both parties signed off on.
What to include
- Specific achievements — what got done, with numbers wherever possible.
- Impact — how that work moved the team or the business.
- Competency ratings on a small set of dimensions you actually assess (most companies use 4–6).
- Growth areas tied to specific behaviours, not personality traits.
- Goals for the next period: specific, measurable, time-bound.
- An overall summary that is honest about both strengths and gaps.
- Space for the employee to record their own perspective.
Frequently asked questions
Should I tie compensation to the review?
Most companies do, and that's fine — but separate the conversations in time. Mixing "here's how you did" with "here's your raise" in the same meeting is shown empirically to make the development conversation worse: people stop listening to feedback the moment they hear a number.
How do I handle a review for an employee on a PIP?
Document the PIP separately and reference it in the review. Don't paper over performance issues in the annual review — but also don't surface anything in the review that wasn't already raised contemporaneously. Surprises in an annual review are a procedural-fairness problem.
Is the employee allowed to disagree with the review?
Yes. Most well-run companies require employees to sign as acknowledgement, with explicit space for a written response. The employee's response becomes part of the file and signals to future reviewers (and tribunals) that there was a genuine two-way conversation.
Legal disclaimer. Performance reviews are admissible evidence. Generic, uniformly-positive reviews followed by a for-cause termination are commonly used in court to undermine the employer's later claim that the employee was a problem. If a review is honest about gaps, it should also be paired with concrete support — coaching, training, a PIP — so the documentary record shows the employer behaved reasonably.
Related templates
Performance improvement plan (PIP)
A measurable, time-bound performance improvement plan with clear expectations, support resources, and review cadence.
OpenDisciplinary warning letter
A progressive-discipline warning letter (verbal, written, or final) that documents the conduct, the standard breached, the consequence, and the path back.
OpenSave it. Brand it. Sign it.
Sign up free to save your templates, brand them with your logo, and send for e-signature — all from your WalnutsHR dashboard.
Your primary HR database is hosted in a Canadian region. Subprocessors and cross-border processing are disclosed in our privacy policy.
30-day free trial · No credit card required